The Verdict That Ended a 'Double Life'
A six-week trial unveiled the fascinating and previously hidden parallel life of a man who argued over 40 cases before the U.S. Supreme Court while secretly shuffling tens of millions at poker tables.
The jury, after three days of deliberation, found Goldstein guilty of tax evasion, willful failure to pay taxes, and submitting false information on mortgage applications. According to the prosecution, Goldstein failed to report millions in gambling winnings while indulging in a lavish lifestyle that included a $225,000 Bentley, luxury watches, and upscale apartments, all while owing millions to the IRS.
Goldstein defended himself by claiming it was all due to 'innocent mistakes' and misplaced trust in his accountants, but the prosecution successfully painted him as a meticulous lawyer who consciously deceived everyone around him.
Testimony of Spider-Man and a Billionaire's Scalpel
The trial in Greenbelt resembled a Hollywood script, partly due to its cast of participants. Among those taking the stand was actor Tobey Maguire, star of Spider-Man, who confirmed that he hired Goldstein in 2020 to help collect a poker debt of over $7 million owed by Texas billionaire Andy Beal.
The trial also revealed the incredible scope of Goldstein's gambling appetite:
-
In 2016, he won an astonishing $26 million in a series of matches, bringing his total earnings for that year to roughly $50 million (including $22 million won in Asia).
-
Since 2022, Goldstein won a staggering $51.4 million in heads-up matches against legendary billionaire Andy Beal.
-
Despite these astronomical wins, Goldstein admitted to being down over $10 million in poker overall, primarily due to losses in regular 'ring games'.
Potential Penalties
While the exact sentence will likely be determined in months, Goldstein faces real prison time. He risks a maximum of five years for tax evasion, but a much harsher sentence—up to 30 years—applies to the false mortgage statements where he concealed a $15 million poker debt from lenders and his own wife. This may be further compounded by additional years for intentional tax delinquency and assisting in preparing false tax returns.
Prosecutors have yet to announce what penalty they will seek for Goldstein. While the maximum sentence is unlikely, he is expected to serve several years in prison.
Sources: PokerNews, NBC News, WHT
